#76
12 November 2012 - 08:09 PM
She may not be alive, and honestly, I think it would be pretty crappy of the writers to try and toss a "Look, she's alive!" at us, but at this point, the only logical conclusion is that Carol is involved with moving Lori's body, whether alive or dead. Honestly, as unprotected as Carol is, I don't see why she would try to recover Lori's dead body without regrouping with the others first.
#77
12 November 2012 - 08:13 PM
#78
12 November 2012 - 08:22 PM
While watching the scene, I was upset when her body wasn't there, because I thought it meant Carl hadn't really shot her. Why would they give that emotional baggage to Carl, build up his character like that, and then take it away from him again? If the satiated zed was, in fact, Lori, then they are taking Carl's biggest moment away from him.
Honestly, though - as much as I hate either of those ideas, I prefer them to the thought that one zombie ATE ALL OF HER, INCLUDING CLOTHES AND BONES. I can't get over how ridiculous that is. It's not shocking, it's not disturbing, it's just... completely unbelievable and ridiculous.
#79
12 November 2012 - 08:32 PM
Because if Glenn had done that why didnt he notice the fat walker?!
Why couldn't he have? The group doesn't seem to be putting down walkers the way they once were. If it's a non-threat, I can see him being a bit more focused on the fact that he's collecting bones from his friend's wife's half eaten body. Also, it did seem as though that walker was about 7-10ft away from Lori, with the blood stain I would assume he tried to drag his fat tuschy as far down the hall as it could make before it collapsed--out of reach&harms way from the bones.
Then again--if the grave IS left open...
Is it Sunday, yet?
#80
12 November 2012 - 08:44 PM
#81
12 November 2012 - 08:49 PM
#82
12 November 2012 - 09:14 PM
#83
12 November 2012 - 09:23 PM
#84
12 November 2012 - 09:36 PM
#85
12 November 2012 - 09:46 PM
It's not possible. It's not. We need to assume that when a walker eats, it's body absorbs the tissue of the meal, or something like that - the fact that not one of the characters have ever said "That is one big pile of walker droppings," just means we need to suspend belief in this regard. That being said, it is NOT POSSIBLE for one walker to consume an entire human being. Physically, he wouldn't bloat, he would explode. Not to mention chomping on the tibula, fibula, rib cage, sternum, and THE SKULL, how did he happen to fit the parts in his mouth?! It's not physically possible, and it's absolutely ridiculous that Nicotero wants us to suspend belief to that extent. We, as viewers, suspend belief quite enough, as we're all watching and loving a show based on the reanimated dead.One grave is Carols even though they havent really found her remains (thats the grave Daryl put the Cherokee rose on),the one next to it is T-Dogs and the open one is Lori's.
This whole plot point has really annoyed me-HOW ON EARTH COULD ALL OF HER FIT INTO THAT WALKERS STOMACH!?
I won't accept it. If it plays out that tubby walker really, truly, honestly was supposed to have eaten her, then it's probably the most ridiculously contrived thing I've ever seen on television, and it's a shame that they followed up one of the most emotionally charged scenes in TV history with that steaming pile of bullshit.
#86
12 November 2012 - 09:54 PM
No no, my bad... He DID eat her. I stand corrected. I missed the Talking Dead last night but apparently Greg Nicatero said that he did eat her. How stupid!!! Why did the zombie drag her and then eat her? Bones and all? Really?
Now THAT is poor writing.
I dont see a problem here. Why is it so hard to imagine a walker devouring a human, bones and all?
#87
12 November 2012 - 09:55 PM
It's not possible. It's not. We need to assume that when a walker eats, it's body absorbs the tissue of the meal, or something like that - the fact that not one of the characters have ever said "That is one big pile of walker droppings," just means we need to suspend belief in this regard. That being said, it is NOT POSSIBLE for one walker to consume an entire human being. Physically, he wouldn't bloat, he would explode. Not to mention chomping on the tibula, fibula, rib cage, sternum, and THE SKULL, how did he happen to fit the parts in his mouth?! It's not physically possible, and it's absolutely ridiculous that Nicotero wants us to suspend belief to that extent. We, as viewers, suspend belief quite enough, as we're all watching and loving a show based on the reanimated dead.
I won't accept it. If it plays out that tubby walker really, truly, honestly was supposed to have eaten her, then it's probably the most ridiculously contrived thing I've ever seen on television, and it's a shame that they followed up one of the most emotionally charged scenes in TV history with that steaming pile of bullshit.
How do you know only one walker ate her? That prison was full of walkers.
#88
12 November 2012 - 10:04 PM
#89
12 November 2012 - 10:11 PM
If it plays out that tubby walker really, truly, honestly was supposed to have eaten her, then it's probably the most ridiculously contrived thing I've ever seen on television, and it's a shame that they followed up one of the most emotionally charged scenes in TV history with that steaming pile of bullshit.
Same, here. Lori wasn't really even my favourite but I've seen her for 2 series now, and imagining rewatching the series again knowing she ends up dying such an emotional death - and next episode is magically bunged in to a Walkers stomach, that will be a buzzkill.
Even if they showed another 1 or 2 zombies around, I could accept it. But as they are putting it to us, it is one FAT bellied walker to signify it has eaten a lot more than we usually see them do.
Lori was always so vocal about not wanting to become a walker, yet her being "buried" in ones guts seems even worse to me than her reanimating and being put down.
#90
12 November 2012 - 10:28 PM
You can see the blood trails of where she is dragged down the hall. Then you see her hair and flesh on the walker. The remains of her body are around the corner. I was thinking this when I watched it and expected them to show it but they didn't. The rest of her is around the corner.
After the show on the talking dead this was also confirmed.
#91
12 November 2012 - 10:30 PM
#92
12 November 2012 - 10:31 PM
#93
12 November 2012 - 10:32 PM
It's not possible. It's not. We need to assume that when a walker eats, it's body absorbs the tissue of the meal, or something like that - the fact that not one of the characters have ever said "That is one big pile of walker droppings," just means we need to suspend belief in this regard. That being said, it is NOT POSSIBLE for one walker to consume an entire human being. Physically, he wouldn't bloat, he would explode. Not to mention chomping on the tibula, fibula, rib cage, sternum, and THE SKULL, how did he happen to fit the parts in his mouth?! It's not physically possible, and it's absolutely ridiculous that Nicotero wants us to suspend belief to that extent. We, as viewers, suspend belief quite enough, as we're all watching and loving a show based on the reanimated dead.
I won't accept it. If it plays out that tubby walker really, truly, honestly was supposed to have eaten her, then it's probably the most ridiculously contrived thing I've ever seen on television, and it's a shame that they followed up one of the most emotionally charged scenes in TV history with that steaming pile of bullshit.
Nicely put. Agree with every stinkin word!
#94
12 November 2012 - 10:35 PM
#95
12 November 2012 - 10:36 PM
Well, if that is true - we shouldn't need to watch a spin off show (especially one not aired in this country) to make sense.
Nicotero confirms .... here now stop about the whole body argument.
Nicotero says they shot Rick’s scenes all in one day, chronologically, so we could see him descend into madness. He also confirms that the bloated walker ate Lori, after dragging her carcass around the corner. Nicotero says the hair in the walker’s mouth was Lori’s, which is a disgusting touch I missed the first time.
#96
12 November 2012 - 10:37 PM
I can buy in to that, and I don't need to see everything on screen - but as mentioned, following last episodes emotional death - and then painting the image only one has eaten her and got a comical fat belly sort of kills the tone.
#97
12 November 2012 - 10:37 PM
Honestly, we shouldn't have to watch TTD to spell out the plot. It's horrible that the zeds dragged her corpse, too, because they've never done that before.Why do you guys keep saying he ate her entire body...?
You can see the blood trails of where she is dragged down the hall. Then you see her hair and flesh on the walker. The remains of her body are around the corner. I was thinking this when I watched it and expected them to show it but they didn't. The rest of her is around the corner.
After the show on the talking dead this was also confirmed.
If the remains are really around the corner, then the writers missed a GOLDEN opportunity to really put AL's acting ability on a pedestal. How do you pass the opportunity for a complete breakdown, and one more goodbye?
They're smarter than that, and that's why I don't buy it. I hate the idea that something is in store for us here, but I see no other possible explanation.
#98
12 November 2012 - 10:40 PM
I just think the made up assumption that her entire body was eaten even to the bones is silly. And the complaining about it is silly. The blood trail is right there to see clear as day.
#99
12 November 2012 - 10:41 PM
She could have been dragged by a walker who was trying to pull her head off to eat but ended up dragging her and gave up and just starting to eat her, the other walkers nearby heard the chomping and chewing and helped the walker eat all of her.
There, problem solved.
#100
12 November 2012 - 10:42 PM
If that's your gripe then fine... But when I watched the show I saw the blood and expected to find the body around the corner. I expected that scene to come but it never came.
I just think the made up assumption that her entire body was eaten even to the bones is silly. And the complaining about it is silly. The blood trail is right there to see clear as day.
and a pack of walkers ate every part of her, bones and all.
There, problem solved.
The Walking Dead Comic Book →
The Walking Dead Comic Series →
Issue 193 Review03 Jul 2019 walking dead, end |
|
||
The Walking Dead Comic Book →
The Walking Dead Comic Series →
The Walking Dead Issue #164 Review15 Feb 2017 Issue 164, Review, Maggie, Carl |
|
||
The Walking Dead Comic Book →
The Walking Dead Comic Series →
Issue 162 Review04 Jan 2017 Issue 162, Rick, Carl, Andrea |
|
||
AMC's The Walking Dead TV Series →
The Walking Dead TV Series →
The Walking Dead Season 7 →
What Did Carl/daryl Whisper?09 Dec 2016 Carl, Negan, daryl |
|
||
The Walking Dead Comic Book →
The Walking Dead Comic Series →
Issue #164 Cover22 Nov 2016 ThatEpicBeastUKnow, Issue 164 |
|