[Sweetsister]

If you could choose 1 character that died in the past 2seasons, and have it so that they didn’t die (storyline was a bit different toallow their survival) Who would you choose and why? It doesn’t have to bea  main loss it could be Randall, the 2dead cops, guys at the bar…whoever



I’d pick Sofia. I’d like to see the dynamics between Carland Sofia. I also think it would improve Carols character, she could have moreof a “mother bear” instinct and force herself to make choices (take gunpractice, carry a gun) that she hasn’t.

[Leela]

Flawless Queen Jacqui.

[Goat]

Ed. Of course. Laundry's slack.

[gracie lou]

Jacqui - I liked her attitude and her heart.

[Gingerbeard]

The Criminal that shot Rick. I really enjoyed his character.

[daenerys]

Shane. I enjoyed watching him on screen and I found I often shared his POV

[Melquiades Estrada]

Goat, on 03 July 2012 - 03:09 AM, said:

Ed. Of course. Laundry's slack.

Amen to that !

[Daisy]

Goat, on 03 July 2012 - 03:09 AM, said:

Ed. Of course. Laundry's slack.

I know, it's all been going downhill since he died. It really was not a comedy club, indeed.

Gingerbeard, on 03 July 2012 - 03:51 AM, said:

The Criminal that shot Rick. I really enjoyed his character.

Are you serious? Because I am. I did enjoy the character. I was a bit shocked the whole scene went so fast, then BAM! BAM! and he was gone. They could have done with having that sort of people around for a wee while...

[Ryan_Dead]

I'd choose Jaqcui aswell. She seemed like a strong female character. Too bad they killed her off.

[I_Follow_You_Axel]

Tank walker. I kinda feel like we never truly got to him...

Seriously though...I miss this guy:



He oozes charisma,

[Kat]

daenerys, on 03 July 2012 - 07:18 AM, said:

Shane. I enjoyed watching him on screen and I found I often shared his POV

Agreed.

[Babs Bladdyblah]

Shane... Dale... Shane... Dale....   Decisions... Decisions.....


One is hot and helps to enrich my fantasy life .... Dale  LOL

The other is just sheer awesome, and should have stuck around, at least until the hunters came along.


I can't decide!!!

[WalkerBaitress]

Sweetsister, on 03 July 2012 - 03:06 AM, said:

I’d pick Sofia. I’d like to see the dynamics between Carland Sofia. I also think it would improve Carols character, she could have moreof a “mother bear” instinct and force herself to make choices (take gunpractice, carry a gun) that she hasn’t.

I'd pick Sophia as well, for the sole reason that

Spoiler

her character is *still* alive in the comics, and she's played a pretty significant (and poignant) role on several fronts, having important relationships with:

• Carl, who is Sophia's friend as well as reluctant "puppy love" interest;
• Carol, who goes insane and commits suicide, leaving Sophia an orphan who has to deal with her mother's horrible decision; and
• Maggie/Glenn, who become Sophia's "adoptive" parents and form a bond with her that continues and grows throughout the comic series.

Pity IMO that the PTB (whoever they were) thought it was necessary to change her storyline so drastically and cut it so cruelly short. The "reason" I've read people giving is that she was maturing too quickly is a bogus excuse IMO--Carl is going to be a teenager, and no one's saying nothin' about him. Just sayin'.

[Sweetsister]

WalkerBaitress, on 03 July 2012 - 11:48 PM, said:

I'd pick Sophia as well, for the sole reason that

Spoiler

her character is *still* alive in the comics, and she's played a pretty significant (and poignant) role on several fronts, having important relationships with:

• Carl, who is Sophia's friend as well as reluctant "puppy love" interest;
• Carol, who goes insane and commits suicide, leaving Sophia an orphan who has to deal with her mother's horrible decision; and
• Maggie/Glenn, who become Sophia's "adoptive" parents and form a bond with her that continues and grows throughout the comic series.

Pity IMO that the PTB (whoever they were) thought it was necessary to change her storyline so drastically and cut it so cruelly short. The "reason" I've read people giving is that she was maturing too quickly is a bogus excuse IMO--Carl is going to be a teenager, and no one's saying nothin' about him. Just sayin'.

I diddnt know that I hope they didnt take Sofia out just to have this big search and open communication between Daryl and Carol...cause I could see Daryl being nice to both of the kids teaching them about living outdoors etc.

[gracie lou]

WalkerBaitress, on 03 July 2012 - 11:48 PM, said:

I'd pick Sophia as well, for the sole reason that

Spoiler

her character is *still* alive in the comics, and she's played a pretty significant (and poignant) role on several fronts, having important relationships with:

• Carl, who is Sophia's friend as well as reluctant "puppy love" interest;
• Carol, who goes insane and commits suicide, leaving Sophia an orphan who has to deal with her mother's horrible decision; and
• Maggie/Glenn, who become Sophia's "adoptive" parents and form a bond with her that continues and grows throughout the comic series.

Pity IMO that the PTB (whoever they were) thought it was necessary to change her storyline so drastically and cut it so cruelly short. The "reason" I've read people giving is that she was maturing too quickly is a bogus excuse IMO--Carl is going to be a teenager, and no one's saying nothin' about him. Just sayin'.

They can get any kid to fill that role that Sophia played in the comic.

comic talk:

Spoiler

I'm actually glad that, hopefully, Maggie and Glenn won't be forced into the parenthood role too soon.

[victorious]

My bbygirl Jacqui <3333333

[Man With A Crossbow]

Obviously Dale! He was a big part of the group and an important character. Hes death was not handled right and they need a "wise old man" in the group. Hershel does not count as a "wise old man" because he explains everything with gods plan.

I dont get why people want Jaqui so bad, she barely had any lines, and btw is rumored to return in season 3. And Shane had to die, and we all know why. Sophia would be nice to have around thinking of her building a relationship with Carl. And Amy's death is important because it made Andrea badass!

[Babs Bladdyblah]

Man With A Crossbow, on 07 July 2012 - 01:42 AM, said:

Obviously Dale! He was a big part of the group and an important character. Hes death was not handled right and they need a "wise old man" in the group. Hershel does not count as a "wise old man" because he explains everything with gods plan.

I dont get why people want Jaqui so bad, she barely had any lines, and btw is rumored to return in season 3. And Shane had to die, and we all know why. Sophia would be nice to have around thinking of her building a relationship with Carl. And Amy's death is important because it made Andrea badass!

Jacqui has been rumored to return in Season 3?

[WalkerBaitress]

gracie lou, on 04 July 2012 - 12:15 AM, said:

They can get any kid to fill that role that Sophia played in the comic.

True, but the new kids won't have the history Sophia does.

(Don't worry, lurking Glen, I'm not whining on your birthday!! Honest!! )

[backwoodsroamer]

It's going to have to be Dale or Jim, cause Glenn is not ready to be head mechanic yet.

[Barry Cade]

gracie lou, on 04 July 2012 - 12:15 AM, said:

They can get any kid to fill that role that Sophia played in the comic.

comic talk:

Spoiler

I'm actually glad that, hopefully, Maggie and Glenn won't be forced into the parenthood role too soon.

Nonsense GL! They'll be...

Spoiler

Looking after Carl all series most likely...

[Ryan_Dead]

Whoaaa! Jaqcui return rumours?!?!

[Babs Bladdyblah]

Ryan_Dead, on 07 July 2012 - 01:14 PM, said:

Whoaaa! Jaqcui return rumours?!?!

I thought you might like that!

[lizbooet2]

I would pick Dale,because he is trying to help and teach everyone,he did'nt panic he was trying to watch out for everyone,he was someone special that I admired plus he was trying to be like the voice of reason.

[gracie lou]

I must say that I've been missing Dale this weekend.