[TigerSingh]

I always had my suspicions about their bonding and how Shane was ready to always sacrifise himself for Carl well sometimes other people like Otis .But the flashback episode where Lori seemed troubled about her marriage before the ZA made me wonder that Lori and Shane might have had an affair before..

[Jimmy Valmer]

 From 30 March 2012 - 07:36 PM:

<br />I always had my suspicions about their bonding and how Shane was ready to always sacrifise himself for Carl well sometimes other people like Otis .But the flashback episode where Lori seemed troubled about her marriage before the ZA made me wonder that Lori and Shane might have had an affair before..<br />

<br /><br /><br />

No way...but carl has learned a lot from shane & is acting a lot like him...and not acting how his father would act.

[Gingerbeard]

Some of the wild theories people come up with on this forum... makes me face palm myself all the time.

[TigerSingh]

 Gingerbeard, on 30 March 2012 - 08:38 PM, said:

Some of the wild theories people come up with on this forum... makes me face palm myself all the time.

Gingerbeard get use to it as we have 7 months to go and this is just the beginning so one can imagine whats coming in between lol

[Gingerbeard]

I just want people to formulate a basis for their theory before sharing it. Because a lot of the theories thrown out there have basically no evidence to back it up. They are just crazy ideas people cook up in their mind. I can't tell you how many times since I've joined this forum, that I've looked at the computer screen in pure confusion from the theories thrown out there.

[Major Tom]

[Gingerbeard]

 Major Tom, on 30 March 2012 - 08:56 PM, said:

My thoughts exactly.

[TigerSingh]

 Gingerbeard, on 30 March 2012 - 08:48 PM, said:

I just want people to formulate a basis for their theory before sharing it. Because a lot of the theories thrown out there have basically no evidence to back it up. They are just crazy ideas people cook up in their mind. I can't tell you how many times since I've joined this forum, that I've looked at the computer screen in pure confusion from the theories thrown out there.

Im sure the writers would come up with a crazy theory if they really wanted to even come up with a shane dad carl son story line away.Now the scenario for the next 7 months : crazy theories, subjects beaten to death about 500 hundred times to only reanimate themselves back  again, news snippets about the series and whats going on presently with the actors.But hopefully the webisodes before October.

[Judari]

 Gingerbeard, on 30 March 2012 - 08:48 PM, said:

I just want people to formulate a basis for their theory before sharing it. Because a lot of the theories thrown out there have basically no evidence to back it up. They are just crazy ideas people cook up in their mind. I can't tell you how many times since I've joined this forum, that I've looked at the computer screen in pure confusion from the theories thrown out there.

I don't think he is but it wouldn't be THAT crazy of a theory. It could be justified by the fact we knew Rick and Lori were having marriage problems (for how long we dont know though), how quickly she turned to Shane for comfort, how crazy Shane was about her and Carl and her reaction to his death by Rick's hands. Its very circumstantial and could be easily argued against but still, not that far out there.

It would make for a very interesting plot twist.

[TigerSingh]

 Judari, on 30 March 2012 - 10:48 PM, said:

I don't think he is but it wouldn't be THAT crazy of a theory. It could be justified by the fact we knew Rick and Lori were having marriage problems (for how long we dont know though), how quickly she turned to Shane for comfort, how crazy Shane was about her and Carl and her reaction to his death by Rick's hands. Its very circumstantial and could be easily argued against but still, not that far out there.

It would make for a very interesting plot twist.

actually more i think of it.it would be a shocking twist as some of the elements are there if they decided to take the story that way..

Edited by TigerSingh, 30 March 2012 - 11:01 PM.

[Judari]

 TigerSingh, on 30 March 2012 - 10:59 PM, said:

actually more i think of it.it would be a shocking twist as some of the elements are there if they decided to take the story that way..

Exactly. Then you have a new twist on how Carl views Rick vice-versa and their relationship from here on out.However, I'm sensing by the way they ended season 2 with Ricktatorship that both Lori and Carl's relationship with Rick will already be strained. I feel like he will be isolated a bit as a leader everyone respects but is nervous/wary of. Therefore they may not need the extra drama Carl being Shane's son would add on to their relationships and the show, especially with all the events we know is about to go down in S3, might be overkill.

[Major Tom]

Here's my idea on theories, The forum charges $5 deposit per theory and refunds $10 if it turns out correct. If wrong the $5 is forfeit.

By the time the new season starts the forum will have made enough money to fly us all to Atlanta for a season premier party. This will be a nice treat for those members who have bankrupted by submitting ridiculous theories.

It's gonna be great.

[Dorkneetah]

Affair could be possible but I do full heartily believe Carl is Rick's son. Carl just felt he lost his father and turned to Shane for guidance, learned leadership from Shane and then now he has his father back. Carl is just trying to learn how to survive and make  his dad proud. Any child in that world who wants to live up to his father's legacy would act like Carl in my opinion.  

Spoiler

As for Judith? I dunno probs Shane's.

[DerpinaKitty]

lol I don't really think so.

[President Merle]

I think the question should be: "Is Carl REALLY Lori's son?"

[auximenes]

 President Merle, on 31 March 2012 - 11:26 AM, said:

I think the question should be: "Is Carl REALLY Lori's son?"

*bah* *dum* *crash*

[DeadCave]

With Shane dead... the question becomes moot.
Shane might've been the sperm donor but Rick definitely was/is the FATHER... it's who raises the child that earns that definition not the one who does his part to make the child.

Edited by DeadCave, 25 May 2012 - 11:31 PM.

[RickGrimeyGrimes]

[Kat]

Um. . .no.  I mean come on. . .consider the total lack of six pack abs!

No abs. . .no theory.

[Gingerbeard]

Why would this thread get bumped?!

[Goat]

What if Carl is his own grandpa?  Time machines.  Think about it.

THINK ABOUT IT.

[Ciren]

Gingerbeard said:

Why would this thread get bumped?!

You peaked interest within given your "Silly R&L Theories" thread.

[Trillian]

 Goat, on 26 May 2012 - 03:59 AM, said:

What if Carl is his own grandpa?  Time machines.  Think about it.

THINK ABOUT IT.

Did Carl go back in time to try to stop the ZA before it started and have a fling with Rick's mom?  I love time travel.

[Leela]

 Goat, on 26 May 2012 - 03:59 AM, said:

What if Carl is his own grandpa?  Time machines.  Think about it.

THINK ABOUT IT.

Oh no! Did Carl do the nasty in the pasty?

[Goat]

 Trillian, on 27 May 2012 - 01:47 AM, said:

Did Carl go back in time to try to stop the ZA before it started and have a fling with Rick's mom?  I love time travel.

Rick is John Connor, basically.  The Z's were sending back zombies to try and murder him and -- well, I won't bore you with the details, but it was the only way.  It was THE ONLY WAY.