[Living Dead Grrrl]

backwoodsroamer, on 05 March 2012 - 07:09 AM, said:

Yeah first Rick's horse, then the deer, the chickens, now the cow.  The four worst moments in TWD.  Yes, I'm a sociopath, so sue me! I also think the original post is pretty goofy too.Warned you about the sociopath thing!

Im not sure why these are the worse moments. In the comic they were at one point

Spoiler

munching on a deer....so animal meals is not a deviation from the original way things were happening, if thats why you hated it.

[Slider13]

My theory is that someone in Randall's group will one day soon become the infamous "Governor". This would make sense  later on and only add to the resentment between Rick's group and his. Oh, and there's no way that Shane lives long enough for season 3.

[TheLibrarian]

I will miss Dale. Already do actually and I am sad he's gone. I'm not upset though. No one is safe.

[Gunslinger]

vikingjedi, on 05 March 2012 - 04:37 AM, said:

Killing an innocent person for a crime they haven't committed is cold blooded murder in any world.

How about for attempted murder when he was on the roof shooting at them as they came out of the bar?

[Voski]

I'm really intrigued on where Daryl's arc will be going. I believe him pushing Rick's gun and him doing it will prove him to be a major arc soon.

[inv1s1ble raven]

Gunslinger, on 05 March 2012 - 03:00 PM, said:

How about for attempted murder when he was on the roof shooting at them as they came out of the bar?

thats why they should have killed him on the fence.  Taking him back as a prisoner only comlicates things.

[Barry Cade]

Gunslinger, on 05 March 2012 - 03:00 PM, said:

How about for attempted murder when he was on the roof shooting at them as they came out of the bar?

Sorry for playing devil's advocate, but...

The three who turned up had been told by an unknown assailant (Mr Grimes esq.) that he had killed their friends (poor innocent Dave and Tony who only wanted to wet their whistles) prior to them (Nate, Randall) shooting. To be frank, although I'm clutching at straws a bit and I do believe that Dave, Tony, Nate et al were right buggers it's got to be said that Randall was not up on that roof without any cause whatsoever, especially given the situation everyone found themselves in.

[Living Dead Grrrl]

Gunslinger, on 05 March 2012 - 03:00 PM, said:

How about for attempted murder when he was on the roof shooting at them as they came out of the bar?

This. Im sorry but if you shoot at me or mine then you're as good as dead. I dont give a shit past that - your rhyme or reason. I would have left him imaplled on the fence to suffer.

[Barry Cade]

Living Dead Grrrl, on 05 March 2012 - 04:00 PM, said:

This. Im sorry but if you shoot at me or mine then you're as good as dead. I dont give a shit past that - your rhyme or reason. I would have left him imaplled on the fence to suffer.

..Aaaand that's why people don't cross you so very much...

[Living Dead Grrrl]

Barry Cade, on 05 March 2012 - 04:13 PM, said:

..Aaaand that's why people don't cross you so very much...

Haha. Well, catch me in the right mood and I might entertain your excuses/reasons/etc. but the outcome still doesnt look so good.

Besides, if you dont take care of the issue right away you risk the situation they're in now with do we murder him/dont we murder him. because I do have humamity, Dale almost had me convinced to give Randy a chance which I feel would turn out badly.

[Grénádé]

Come on let's not forget Rick was the only one to step up and shoot Sophia in the head.

[nb08d]

iWalkingDead, on 05 March 2012 - 04:39 AM, said:

no, anyone know simple arithmetic mixed with logic? WHICH OF COURSE AMC WONT UNDERSTAND

Rick- Too Little
Shane- Too Much
Daryl- Medium

-2+2+0= 0
WHY CANT DARYL SHANE RICK be the only people alive already

I think that's what the title of the episode was referring to. Judge Jury Executioner... I think Shane is the Judge, Rick is the Jury, and Daryl is the Executioner. Rick will take arguments and weight the options, but has trouble making a clear decision  and following through based on the arguments. Shane also weighs the options but often goes with his own gut feelings and usually makes the call in the end. Daryl is the executioner cause he does whatever is best for the group based on their desicion, and follows through with the decision (looking for sophia, Dale).

Also, slightly after this plot line in the comics...

Spoiler

Rick kinda goes nuts from the stress of being the single leader, and the group forms a committee to make the decisions. I assume this would include Rick, Shane, and Daryl.

[zombiehunter]

Will miss Jeffery DeMun. Great actor.

[babyMOMMAdrama]

What the hell is the purpose of this poll???

[Ansceniiiic]

zombiehunter, on 05 March 2012 - 06:55 PM, said:

Will miss Jeffery DeMun. Great actor.

Agreed! question is, who's going to inherit the RV?

[Ciren]

I wasn't fooled into the whole "it's Merle!" facade at first, but then fell into it thinking Daryl was shooting Merle.

Then my opinion changed to it being Shane, then to finally being Randall.

I was all kinds of wrong.

[THE WALKING DEAD ADDICT]

Rest In Peace Dale...

In nomine Patris et Filii et Spiritus Sancti

(Thats latin for In the name of the father, and the son, and the holy spirit).

[SkunkWorks]

backwoodsroamer, on 05 March 2012 - 04:03 AM, said:

I have no idea where this is going, but we are being shown time and again Rick lacks the resolve to be a good leader. He doesn't have the "stomach" for the job.  Shane is too much.  Rick is too little. Is Daryl juuuust right?

It would be a great time for Abraham Ford to show up on the farm.

Attached Files

•  abraham1.jpg   36.62K   94 downloads

[ComptonAssJer]

i dont like his charactor sometimes, other times i do. thought it was kind of random how he died yesterday.

[Ebusus]

I vote for Daryl to be the new leader. He combines the best of Shane and Rick whom I now hope will die both soon.

[backwoodsroamer]

Living Dead Grrrl, on 05 March 2012 - 02:48 PM, said:

Im not sure why these are the worse moments. In the comic they were at one point

Spoiler

munching on a deer....so animal meals is not a deviation from the original way things were happening, if thats why you hated it.

Yes, didn't like it in the spoiler thing either. My comment got here when multiple threads were combined. It made sense in the original thread. Honest! Really!

[journeynsolace]

nb08d, on 05 March 2012 - 06:49 PM, said:

I think that's what the title of the episode was referring to. Judge Jury Executioner... I think Shane is the Judge, Rick is the Jury, and Daryl is the Executioner. Rick will take arguments and weight the options, but has trouble making a clear decision  and following through based on the arguments. Shane also weighs the options but often goes with his own gut feelings and usually makes the call in the end. Daryl is the executioner cause he does whatever is best for the group based on their desicion, and follows through with the decision (looking for sophia, Dale).

Also, slightly after this plot line in the comics...

Spoiler

Rick kinda goes nuts from the stress of being the single leader, and the group forms a committee to make the decisions. I assume this would include Rick, Shane, and Daryl.

I haven't read the comics. Who is on the committee in them?

Personally, it's a small group (14 people). I could see the need for a committee if the group were larger, but I'd be thinking of my exit strategy if I was suddenly cut out of the decision making in a small group. (This was one of my irks with Lost too, but I liked how they actually addressed that situation of just a few people seemingly "taking charge" and how the others in the group handled that fact.)

Also, I thought it was more Judge=Rick, Jury=Everyone in the debate scene, and Executioner=Daryl

[Rawcore]

I honestly have no idea how Dale survived past the first week of the outbreak, he's clearly hopeless when it comes to handling roamers

[backwoodsroamer]

journeynsolace, on 06 March 2012 - 02:39 AM, said:

I haven't read the comics. Who is on the committee in them?

Personally, it's a small group (14 people). I could see the need for a committee if the group were larger, but I'd be thinking of my exit strategy if I was suddenly cut out of the decision making in a small group. (This was one of my irks with Lost too, but I liked how they actually addressed that situation of just a few people seemingly "taking charge" and how the others in the group handled that fact.)

Also, I thought it was more Judge=Rick, Jury=Everyone in the debate scene, and Executioner=Daryl

Ever seen a small group in action. What we see on the show is exactly what happens. A few people call the shots while the others amble along with the herd.  Not flaming you. I've just seen the same thing happen over and over again.  Even seen the supposed leader in the herd while a subordinate led.  It's a sad fact, most people are sheep.

[backwoodsroamer]

SkunkWorks, on 05 March 2012 - 10:16 PM, said:

It would be a great time for Abraham Ford to show up on the farm.

The right man in the right place at the right time?